Some of the more recent noteworthy Academy Award Oscar winners and nominees have been over-shadowed by a now notorious face slapping event. One such Oscar was the best motion picture award (reviewed by the New York Times) to CODA (child of deaf adults) -- a first major award for a film with a predominantly deaf cast.
The social uproar occurred with the recent Hollywood Academy Awards of the Oscars when the best actor prior to his award being announced unexpectedly walked on stage, slapped hard the comedian host for making a joke about the actor's wife. Once the actor returned to his seat, he proceeded to utter a few curse word threats warning the comedian not to mention his wife's name. All for which the actor ultimately apologized later.
Given that the comedian's joke referred to the actor's wife's bald head, which is due to a medical condition, I am of the view these type jokes should be off limits. Making jokes about people who have a medical condition seems more than inappropriate to me to say the least -- such as how they look, walk, talk, react, and more. Not known is if the comedian knew the wife shaved her head because of a medical condition, though this was public knowledge. There still is no excuse for the actor's actions.
The actor's reaction, after I observed him initially laughing at the joke, was quite an illegal physical assault on the comedian for which the actor could and, perhaps, should have been arrested on the spot, removed from the premises, and maybe even jailed. How the whole situation was handled is another issue I won't even discuss further here. There still was no excuse for the actor's behavior.
If an individual has a medical condition which they are comfortable publicly discussing and choose to laugh at or make jokes about, then that makes such humor about themselves more acceptable but not otherwise in my opinion.
*. *. *
Liza Minnelli, celebrating the 50th anniversary of "Cabaret", the film that earned her an Oscar for best actress years ago, presented the best picture final award in spite of the adverse effects she was experiencing from medical problems.
Lady Gaga was a class act keeping the presentation going by assisting Ms Minnelli without ever being patronizing or awkward. She, Liza, was enabled to retain her dignity despite the variety of medical issues that have challenged her functional abilities in recent years.
Lady Gaga and Liza Minnelli present Best Picture Oscars 2022. ABC Live
My years as a Speech-Language Pathologist I worked with a rehabilitation team of other therapy disciplines and medical professionals. Though I initially trained and planned to work with children who had severely disordered language, I evolved into working primarily with adult patients of all ages but mostly older adults, in hospitals, eventually in long term care including skilled nursing in my later years of practice.
I encountered individuals with many varying medical diagnoses that included a broad variety of communication, swallowing, cognitive and related difficulties, some such as Ms Minnelli has encountered. In every instance with all patients, whatever the diagnoses, their retaining personal dignity and being respected by all professionals, family members, friends, and any others they might encounter has been a vital element in enabling them as human beings to optimize achieving their highest potential functioning level of which they are capable at any given point in time.
They and all of us want little more for ourselves than respect and dignity, too, even if our only issues are that we've become old. Maybe we've reached an age we tire more easily. Perhaps we're less able than we once were in some functional areas ... vision or hearing not as sharp ... thinking sequentially a little slower ... recall sometimes short-circuited ... some words not always available ... feeling overwhelmed occurring more readily ... walking not as fast or far, or not at all. We may occasionally make mistakes in our words or speech that are not over-looked by some others as similar errors when we were younger that we laughed about then.
So it is, that I've been so impressed with Lady Gaga as she has shared the stage with Tony Bennett who has Alzheimer's and now Liza Minnelli coping with her own, but different challenges.
Here's Liza in her prime singing the title song ... in the 1972 movie "Cabaret" of that Broadway show. The setting is:
"Berlin, 1931. As Nazism rises in Germany, flamboyant American Sally Bowles (Liza Minnelli) sings in a decadent nightclub and falls in love with a British language teacher (Michael York) ... [this] carefree, tolerant and fragile cabaret world is about to be crushed under the boot of the Nazis as Berlin becomes a trap from which Sally"s German friends will not escape".
That government's oppression and Russia's behavior toward Ukraine today is what an autocracy offers that all should remember come elections in our own and other countries. Be not fooled by lying autocrats with their appeasers appearing to be different with promises of enrichment for all.
Perhaps you have some thoughts about some of the topics I've mentioned?
I am totally clueless about movies, oscars etc but was repeatedly sent clips of the slap incident by friends. I thought that the joke was in very poor taste but, the slap in that particular environment was uncalled for. Smith will pay a very high price.
ReplyDeleteHe resigned from the Academy. Later they penalized him from attending any Academy awards shows or activities for 10 years. Any other effects such as making more movies, being nominated for any awards remains to be seen.
DeleteLady Gaga is a class act. Her interactions with Tony Bennett and now Liza Minnelli show that she values human dignity and possesses an empathy that is sorely lacking in so many in all walks of life. I often say that it costs little, if nothing, to be kind. She showcases that.
ReplyDeleteI couldn't agree more.
DeleteI could not agree with you more in your opinion of Lady Gaga. I have the greatest respect for her in the manner in which she easily and honestly gives both the stage and her support to her elder performers. She doesn't just talk about being a good person. She actively shows that she IS a good person.
ReplyDeleteWelcome to ATW! I'm glad to know others recognize and appreciate Lady Gaga's essence well beyond her musical talents.
DeleteI agree that jokes about someone's medical condition are quite unacceptable, unless as you say the person in question also laughs about it. And yes, the important thing when someone has a disabling condition is to respect their personal dignity as far as possible. As you may know, my sister has been bedbound with motor neurone disease for many years but her husband and daughter make sure her personal dignity is maintained.
ReplyDeleteI didn’t know about your sister and am sorry to hear she’s having to cope with that but glad she continues to be respected.
DeleteI so agree with your comments about the bad joke, the assault, and Liza's poor health. I watched the Oscars, too.
ReplyDeleteSeems like common sense to me if we care about others feelings.
DeleteI don't think her bald head was a medical condition and if it is, so are bald men, but she looked gorgeous and the joke didn't appear to put her down. I have no idea how it'll play out, but I don't watch any award shows as I rarely know the character or films. Sad however you look at it
ReplyDeleteThere are a multitude of news stories reporting and quoting Jada Pickett Smith's report of having the autoimmune disease alopecia.
Delete"Alopecia areata is an autoimmune disorder that causes your hair to come out, often in clumps the size and shape of a quarter." as described in this link: https://www.webmd.com/skin-problems-and-treatments/guide/alopecia-areata
"For many women, alopecia can be a source of embarrassment and emotional pain, especially considering how much value society traditionally assigns to hair as a marker of feminine beauty, status and personal identity...as described in this NPR link: https://www.npr.org/2022/03/28/1089133964/whats-behind-the-slap-will-smith-gave-chris-rock-at-the-oscars
I even know of some men with alopecia who are equally sensitive to their hair loss who go to great lengths to overcome or disguise the problem. They are not receptive to attention in jokes or otherwise being focused on their hair loss.
I don't know how much hair she loses and she may well have chosen to shave her head as some do, but that does not negate the possible sensitivity she, some women and men with the disease may have. I did see the award show and she did register a less than accepting facial expression in response immediately following the joke. This appeared to stop her husband's laughing, followed by his going onstage. Just because some viewers might think she "looked gorgeous and the joke didn't appear to put her down" does not negate how she may personally have felt. Jokes about any individual's medical condition I believe to be unacceptable as I described above. ;-)
It would be interesting to know (and we won't) how much her previous relationship with Rock played into this. They did a series of movies together and traveled around the world to promote them. Does her desire for an open marriage (which she has vocalized on her Red Table) play into this. If Rock is a gentleman, he won't likely tell the media, but seems like Smith's insecurity could have been a factor either way-- something his wife encouraged. I hadn't watched Red Table but since the event, I've seen some clips. Many people have affairs but not brag about them to the public
DeleteI don't know anything about all that which may well have had some bearing on the emotions each felt. Whatever that relationship does not alter or excuse the behaviors of these adults on this Oscar awards TV program IMHO.
DeleteDear Joared, your entire posting reflected an empathy and wisdom that is so sorely lacking in many of our elected officials--be they the former president or Putin or the senator from Missouri (where I live) or other senators who seem to have lost both their backbones and their integrity. A greediness for power seems to motivate/fuel so many politicians around the globe. And unless we somehow get out the vote, the authoritarian regimes will crush citizens around the world who long for peace and for equality. I find myself living now as my parents must have lived in the 1930s--the decade in which I was born. They saw the rise of Nazism and of people like Lindbergh who seemed to applaud what was happening in Germany. Mom and Dad must have felt then as I am feeling now--that somehow, we must find the Oneness that connects us all--despite our fears and our lack of will and our confusion. Let us, during this week especially, find within ourselves the hope that all shall be well . . . if we do our part. Peace in that deep center of yourself where wholeness dwells.
ReplyDeletePeace is indeed what we need. Thanks for sharing your thoughts that describe observations you’ve made and concerns many of us share.
DeleteI have not watched the Oscars for years so I didn't see the stuff with Will Smith, but I am so sorry that he gave in to his anger. I have been fascinated to watch all he's been doing with the backing of National Geographic and the project "Welcome to Earth". If you haven't seen it please look it up. It shows him going to places never seen before on earth and it's extraordinary.
ReplyDeleteI haven't seen the program you mentioned or viewed an entire program of anything Smith has been in. That Earth program does sound interesting.
Delete